If there's something that you're looking for for your pet and they don't carry it at one of PetPeople's multiple locations around Northeast Ohio, it probably doesn't exist. This local franchise has it all, and it's of the highest quality and best value. Every pet toy, treat, leash and cage is available here, and they mostly sell top-end brands. While you might pay a little more for the premium products, PetPeople has a great customer rewards' program that lets customers get their 13th bag of pet food free, plus a rewards system that'll funnel gift certificates back your way. Their in-house doggie baked goods look good enough to eat; we haven't tried them yet, but they're probably awesome, at least judging by our dog's reaction.
Multiple locations, petpeoplestores.com.