Best Reality Show Contestant

Ashley Spencer

Yes, You're the One That I Want was the one that made you turn the channel every time. But even if we weren't total suckers for really hot local girls -- Maybe I'll see her on West Sixth! Maybe she'll be drunk enough to talk to me! -- this Massillon native would've made NBC's pick-the-next-Grease-cast competition show watchable. At 22, she's got Barbie-doll looks -- which is probably why she once starred in the traveling Barbie Live show. And she can belt it like Olivia Newton-John. Ashley was bounced in the final episode, but she's still star-bound: Her appearance helped land her a starring role in a Broadway production of Hairspray.