The zealot in redface pictured above, outside Progressive Field before the Indians' home opener this afternoon, was featured on Deadspin and instantly became the object of scorn and disbelief nationwide.
Who would have the balls and the stomach, most reasonable Americans asked, to confront a person belonging to a specific race of people while dressed and garishly made up in a costume which mocks (or at the very least trivializes) that specific race of people, and then inform that person that he could not possibly be — and in fact, had no right to be — offended by the costume and the makeup .
But that's precisely what happened.
This guy, whose last name was Rodriguez and who fancied himself a kind of spokesman or public defender, strode over to the Anti-Wahoo protesters, many of them from the American Indian Movement, with a mind to spar. (This was probably about 2 p.m., before the tallest tidal wave of endurance-pre-gamers descended from bars in the vicinity). He kept insisting that he was an Indians fan — an Indians fan! — (i.e. that his actions, thereby, weren't subject to the scrutiny of law or taste?)
"It's Cleveland pride," he later told a Channel 5 reporter. "That's all it's about."
When asked if he'd feel comfortable arriving to a game in blackface, you know, like if his team were the Cleveland Blacks, he repeated only that he was an Indians' fan.
Though protesters have been railing against Chief Wahoo at opening day for decades, the recent vocal opposition by city councilmen and the "historic stance" of the Plain Dealer's editorial board has pushed the issue more centrally into local conversations.
The crazy thing about this afternoon's protest in general and the encounter above specifically was the lengths to which the Pro-Wahoo crowd is prepared to go (and here I primarily mean logical lengths) to deny the legitimacy of those offended by the logo.
The staunch, redfaced Rodriguez refused to acknowledge that the Native American man standing before him — Robert Roche, of the Apache Nation — could possibly take offense. Rorche literally told him he was offended by Chief Wahoo and the use of tribal feathers and redface, and Rodriguez just kept shaking his head.
It's actually a shame for the civil Wahoo supporters that their comrades put on such an embarrassing and primitive display this afternoon. Only twice in three hours did Pro-Wahoo folks talk politely with the protesters about the root of their opposition and try to explain their own difficulties with the dehumanizing logo. (One man turned his Wahoo hat around as a little peace offering).
For the most part, though, passers-by hurled insults. A handful of boozy risk-takers sporting "Keep the Chief" tees walked directly in front of those holding signs, to taunt. Others distributed individual middle-fingers to each protester while inviting them to fuck themselves. Others launched the familiar hate speech — "Go back to the reservation," etc.
Here's a quick rundown of the rhetorical strategies at work today. (All of this I personally overheard.)
1) De-legitimize the anti-Wahoo argument itself:
—"It's not racist!"
—"No one thinks it's racist!" (Bold indeed, given the protest).
—"Talk to Obama if you think it's racist."
—"It's a fucking cartoon. Come on."
2) De-legitimize the anti-Wahoo protesters themselves:
—"They're not even Indians." (Quite a few of the protesters weren't Native American. Nice work!)
—"It's funny cuz they all look homeless."
—"Get a job!"
—"Find something better to protest."
3) Legitimize oneself.
—"I went to college!" (???)
—"That guy has four college degrees." (About a fellow, a white male, who looked Robert Roche in the face and told him that his life could not possibly have been affected by Chief Wahoo, then proceeded merrily down the "Fighting Irish" argument line, except with the Dallas Cowboys.)
—(Holding Wahoo hat aloft, a la Catholic Priest) "I'm Cherokee!"
—I'm an Indian! I am! My grandfather would laugh at all of you.
4) Legitimize team and logo by really original, clever comparison.
—"Where's PETA for the Detroit Tigers? Huh? Where's PETA?"
—"I'm Irish. You don't see me complaining about Notre Dame." (ENOUGH ALREADY.)
—"I guess the Dallas Cowboys should get rid of that team too, because I'm offended!"
5) Baselessly and violently insult protesters:
—"Fuck you. Fuck you. Fuck you. Fuck you. Fuck you."
—"You're DumbASSes. Hear me? DumbASSes!"
6) Trivialize argument while shifting focus and blame.
—"We're trying to celebrate an American pastime." (i.e. Stop ruining my day).
—"I'm a season ticket holder. Why don't you come to a game before you protest my team." (Many of the protesters were Indians' fans as well).
—From above: "It's about Cleveland Pride. That's all it's about."
7) Outright Wahoo-specific chants and noise-making.
—"Keep the Chief! Keep the Chief! Keep the Chief!
—(Obnoxious Indian battle cry ululation stuff.)
We’re keeping you informed…
...and it’s what we love to do. From local politics and culture to national news that hits close to home, Scene Magazine has been keeping Cleveland informed for years.
It’s never been more important to support local news sources, especially as we all deal with the ramifications of the coronavirus pandemic. Almost everything Scene is about -- our stories, our events, our advertisers -- comes down to getting together. With events on hold, and no print distribution for the foreseeable future, every little bit helps.
A free press means accountability and a well-informed public, and we want to keep our unique and independent reporting available for many, many years to come.
If quality journalism is important to you, please consider a donation to Scene. Every reader contribution is valuable and so appreciated, and goes directly to support our coverage of critical issues and neighborhood culture. Thank you.