Music » Livewire

Edwin McCain

With Maia Sharp. Friday, July 2, at the Odeon.

by

Edwin McCain
  • Edwin McCain

Because bland people who wear bland clothes and have bland conversations at bland dinner parties in bland houses with bland landscape prints on the wall need more bland background music to play once the Train CD ends, South Carolina's Edwin McCain puts out a bland new album every two years or so. Really, though, what else would you expect from a guy initially championed by Hootie and the Blowfish and propelled to Top 40 fame in 1997 thanks to his sappy ballad ("I'll Be") being spotlighted on Dawson's Creek?

McCain's latest, Scream and Whisper, neither screams nor whispers -- it's a 14-song monotone of cloying lyrical pap set to generic roots-pop arrangements, guided by a producer who obviously knows where the "Remove Soul Here" button is on the studio console. McCain croons cringeworthy romantic clichés by the bucketload ("I'll put all the stars back in your sky," "I couldn't love you more if I tried," etc.). And yet he manages to out-insipid those with clunky attempts at capital-I-Important tunes about illegal aliens ("White Crosses") and Jim Crow-era black musicians ("Good Enough"). Recommended only if you find Matchbox Twenty and Shawn Mullins too challenging.

comment

Add a comment