Film » Screens

Habitat for Inhumanity

The "asylums" depicted in The Magdalene Sisters undermine both the Catholic Church and the popular image of Ireland.


Nora-Jane Noone gives a powerful performance as an orphan who defies a repressive system.
  • Nora-Jane Noone gives a powerful performance as an orphan who defies a repressive system.

The last thing the Roman Catholic Church needs at this point is another exposé of its misdeeds. The shock of the pedophilia scandals and of the official coverups isn't going away anytime soon. Collection-plate revenues continue to dwindle as the lawsuits multiply, and even many fervent Catholics are questioning their church -- if not their own faith.

The latest bolt of lightning to hit the sacristy is Peter Mullan's The Magdalene Sisters, a grim, faintly fictionalized examination of Catholic Ireland's infamous "Magdalene Asylums." In what amounted to a program of forced labor, thousands of so-called "fallen women" were incarcerated -- sometimes for life -- for "moral crimes" that ranged from sassy backtalk to giving birth out of wedlock. First established in 1767 as a refuge for prostitutes, the asylums evolved in the 20th century into a kind of church-sponsored, family-endorsed gulag, where the embattled inmates washed laundry seven days a week for exactly zero pay and the Sisters of Mercy tormented them with laws of silence, harangues about chastity and piety, beatings, and sexual humiliation. Under increasing pressure, the last of these hellish institutions finally closed its doors in 1996.

Writer-director Mullan, who was raised Catholic in Scotland, is not the first muckraker to tackle this long-secret scandal. Singer Joni Mitchell recorded her outraged ode "Magdalene Laundries" in 1995, and in 1997 the disturbing British documentary Sex in a Cold Climate was released. In 1999, former nun Patricia Burke Brogan wrote a play, Eclipsed, about Ireland's "fallen women," and 60 Minutes jumped on the bandwagon soon thereafter. More may not be better in this case, but Mullan's dramatized account of three young women sent off to an asylum near Dublin in the 1960s is powerful stuff, if a bit plodding and schematic. It is likely to be the last word (the issue of reparations aside) on a long episode of cruelty enacted in the name of redemption.

The embattled inmates we meet here are fictional, but archetypal. Raped by a drunk at a family wedding, delicate Margaret (Anne-Marie Duff) is foolish enough to speak up, and her shamed family quickly ships her off to oblivion. Rose (Dorothy Duffy) disturbs the public tranquility with an illegitimate child, who is quickly snatched from the mother's grasp, while she's thrown into the clink. Bernadette (Nora-Jane Noone) commits two crimes: She's an orphan, and she's just a bit too pretty for the schoolyard, which makes her a danger to herself and the leering boys nearby. The Taliban couldn't have come up with a more radical solution to her problems. Of the film's three heroines, screen-newcomer Noone's Bernadette may be the most stirring -- not least for the clear-eyed fury with which she comes to defy the absolute power of both the regime and the sexual repression that fuels it.

Filmmaker Mullan (Orphans), who's also worked as an actor in cutting-edge dramas such as Trainspotting and Riff-Raff, gives us not the photogenic Ireland of lilting song and magical myth, as seen in some other recent films, but a barren, gray vision of a land in the grip of tyranny. To avoid growing Irish resistance to his movie, he actually shot it at an old convent in Dumfries, Scotland, but there's no mistaking his view of sanctimonious violence. His Sister Bridget (Geraldine McEwan) is a starched reminder of every oppressive nun who ever smacked a schoolchild with a yardstick, and then some: She's Nurse Ratched in a habit, a twisted prison warden who believes in nothing so much as the corruption of men's souls. Meanwhile, the less said the better about the vile and deceitful Father Fitzroy (Daniel Costello), especially his relationship to a slow-witted asylum inmate named Crispina (Eileen Walsh). The seminaries are sparsely enough populated already.

In Sex in a Cold Climate, documentarian Steve Humphries interviewed survivors of the Magdalene Asylums to chilling effect and vividly chronicled the terrors they underwent. Mullan's fictionalized approach lacks some of Humphries' moral force, but that hasn't kept the church from condemning his work. Vatican officials denounced The Magdalene Sisters when it was released in Europe last year, and a spokesman for the U.S.-based Catholic League quickly defended the asylums as appropriate to the social standards of their day. Yes, and the Inquisition was deemed appropriate to the standards of its day.

Can reformers inside the Catholic Church weather the current storm and make the church relevant to new generations, or will the old guard, which resists change at any cost, keep fiddling while Rome burns? Peter Mullan raises the question once more in this blunt, heartfelt cry of outrage -- at the moment when it most urgently needs to be addressed.

We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Cleveland Scene. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Cleveland Scene, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.

Email us at

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club for as little as $5 a month.