Cleveland’s best sandwiches? Our critic weighs in


Consider the humble sandwich. A pinnacle of gustatory efficiency, the soaring stack-up of breads, meats, cheeses, and assorted condiments has long been the star of blue-collar lunch boxes. So as home to generations of working-class heroes, it’s no surprise that Cleveland claimed three spots on Esquire’s recent list of the country’s best sandwiches, as pointed out by my colleague yesterday***. Among the editors’ 39 top picks were the battered-and-fried Trailer Park Monte Cristo, from the Beachland Ballroom (15711 Waterloo Road; 216-383-1124), the peerless corned beef from Slyman’s (3106 St. Clair, 216-621-3760), and the classic Polish Boy from Freddie’s Rib House (1431 St. Clair Avenue; 216-575-1750). Worthy choices, all, but far from a complete rundown. Here are a few sandwiches we’d add to the list: ... The Hot Italian Melt Bar & Grilled An overstuffed extravaganza of salami, ham, pepperoni, sun-dried-tomato pesto, roasted garlic, and provolone, on buttery slabs of golden, griddled bread, this two-fisted sandwich delivers all the savor of a first-rate pizza -- only better. 14718 Detroit, 216-226-3699 The Hot Pastrami Mister Brisket A dribble-down-your-chin delight, this plush, peppery tower of tender pastrami, melty swiss, and spicy mustard on rye always leaves us sated, satisfied, and slightly grease-stained – a small price to pay for such a fabulous tango of textures and tastes. 2156 S. Taylor Rd., Cleveland Hts., 216-932-8620 The Cuban Lelolai Bakery & Café Hot off the (sandwich) presses, this crusty, crunchy combo of freshly roasted pork, ham, Swiss, mustard, pickles, and garlic is our perennial pick for the best Latino-style comfort food. 1889 West 25th St., 216-771-9956 The Croque Monsieur Le Petit Triangle Café Earning its place in our Pantheon of Great Sandwiches, find this luscious fried confluence of lean, honey-glazed ham and nutty Gruyère on batter-dipped challah. Highlighting its savory sweetness, a stroke of creamy béchamel brings out the ou là là. 1881 Fulton Avenue, 216-281-1881 In their search for great sandwiches, Esquire also got the skinny from Cleveland celeb chef Mike Symon. For a mouthwatering description of Symon’s favorite sammy, plus a recipe, click here. ***Fellow foodie and vegetarian Rebecca Meiser stumbled into a common trap in her blog yesterday about Cleveland’s top sandwiches: She confused a Po’ Boy with a Polish Boy. Any meat-eater worth his or her salty slabs of goodness would know there’s a world o’ diff between the two. The first – the Po’ Boy -- is a Nawlin’s specialty, featuring breaded and fried oysters on French bread, topped with tartar sauce, sliced tomato, and shredded lettuce; fried catfish or shrimp make acceptable subs for the oysters. The second – the Polish Boy – is a Cleveland fave, starring kielbasa, a tomato-y hot sauce, coleslaw, and french fries on white. A popular soul-food staple, the Polish Boy has the added attraction of reflecting Cleveland’s tastefully mixed ethnicity, sort of like a love child conceived from the union of Hot Sauce Williams with Sokolowski’s University Inn. Freddie’s Rib House got Esquire’s nod for its Polish Boy, of course, not for a Po’ Boy. – Elaine T. Cicora


We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Cleveland Scene. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Cleveland Scene, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.

Email us at

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club for as little as $5 a month.