Yes, this is how business is done around here, as county commissioner Tim Hagan was so fond of reminding everyone during the whole half-billion-dollar convention center give-away to his developer-friend Chris Kennedy. What he meant: behind closed doors.
And so it goes with the Ameritrust building at Euclid and East Ninth. Commissioners bought the long-vacant building — which somehow manages to look like an Irish public-housing highrise and “architecturally significant” — in 2005 from Dick Jacobs for the grand price of $22 million. The plan: put in some money and have a brand-new-looking county HQ. But a few unforeseen developments screwed that plan up seven ways from Sunday.
County commissioners have reportedly thrown as much as $40 million into the building, but then said last year — with the Medical Mart/convention center issue boiling on the front burner and site selection still burning holes in key developers’ pockets — that they couldn’t afford to move forward and would acquiesce to the plans of a very-connected developer, Doug Price of the K&D Group. Price said he had a major tenant lined up to help him turn the old building into a hotel and gathering place, but then Price backed out early this week after that tenant bailed and any hopes of financing fell through.
But maybe this was the plan all along. Commissioners didn’t float the idea of buying a county HQ with sales-tax revenue, to make it an entranceway to the new convention center development, until after the Med Mart deal was done. This would necessitate a move and provide the cash flow, as Commissioner Jimmy Dimora told Cleveland Council members, “to fill another one of your vacant buildings elsewhere downtown.”
This was all before the lastest round of federal corruption indictments came down last week, though, which confirmed that Dimora and Auditor Frank Russo are indeed up to their doughy faces in what prosecutors allege is a fat mess of greedy shenanigans.
Now, Price looks like the worst possible person to have been sitting on the county’s Ameritrust crater, waiting for something that hasn’t happened. Not only are investigators interested in Dimora’s role in the Ameritrust sale and his dealings with K&D, but they allege Price paid Dimora and Co. a series of bribes for the county engineer’s office to locate to K&D’s Stonebridge development downtown.
Yeah, it might be wise for him to “just go away.” Maybe to Florida with Kevin Kelley.
Now, commissioners are saying that they have “few prospects to sell” either the Ameritrust building or county HQ. So … why not move there with the proceeds of the sale of county HQ?
County administrator Jim McCafferty said Wednesday that “tough economic times” led to poor funding prospects for Price. That’s all. And it’s just coincidental, he added, that the county might go hunting for a new county HQ soon and will have to ignore the building it already purchased and invested millions in to be that new HQ.
“At this point, there’s no plan to put them together,” he says. “It would be pretty expensive to make it work this way.”
The Ameritrust building’s floor plans don’t suit it for the county’s needs, says McCafferty, so the original goal was to demolish it and build from scratch. To make it work as is would require many millions more. The new plan: sell it to recoup the millions lost and counting.
So does McCafferty think this is a “Thanks Dick!” situation? “I was not here when all that was done, so I don’t know all the thinking that went into it, but it’s not a straight shot for us to go up there.” Not anymore.
What’s also confusing is why this topic never came up when Med Mart developer Chris Kennedy was selling his reasoning for why Dick Jacob’s Key Tower and the current county HQ would be a better neighbor to the new development — and cheaper — than Forest City’s Tower City site, which wouldn’t need to buy up county HQ at all.
On Wednesday, Forest City co-chairman Sam Miller said the county “overpayed drastically” for the Ameritrust building. (And he knows a thing or two about how the county can get gouged.) But Miller wouldn’t speculate about how much county HQ’s location right next to the chosen convention center site on the Mall may have weighed on commissioners’ final selection.
“I don’t know what those guys were thinking,” he claims.
Is he pissed? “I don’t get mad,” he answers. “What do you get?” he is asked. “Nothing,” he says, then giggles as he politely bids adieu. — Dan Harkins
We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Cleveland Scene. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Cleveland Scene, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.
Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Support Local Journalism.
Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club
Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.
Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.