Cleveland Reaches $45,000 Settlement With Man Who Sued After Arrest for Getting Groceries During May 2020 Curfew

By

comment
CLEVELAND POLICE OFFICERS DIRECT TRAFFIC AWAY FROM THE LORAIN CARNEGIE BRIDGE DURING THE CURFEW PERIOD/SCENE
  • Cleveland police officers direct traffic away from the Lorain Carnegie bridge during the curfew period/Scene

Update: The city of Cleveland has reached a $45,000 settlement with Mehdi Mollahsani, who filed a federal civil rights lawsuit after being arrested on May 31, 2020 while attempting to retrieve a grocery order while the city was under a curfew following unrest from the George Floyd protest earlier that day.

The curfew zones and times were almost immediately criticized as over-broad overreactions for which the city provided little to no justification but nevertheless included militarized officers and blocked highway exits.



Regardless, in accordance with the order, residents who lived downtown were asked to remain at home except for work purposes or to gather essential items.

Mollahasani says in his lawsuit that he did just that — leaving his residence on East 9th to retrieve an Instacart order from a delivery driver who had been stopped by cops outside the restricted downtown zone. Before making it four blocks, he was confronted by Cleveland police officers who "harassed him, and baselessly accused him of looting."



Mollahasani hadn't even attended the protest the previous day, let alone participated in any looting.

Despite showing proof of residency, and despite doing nothing more extraordinary than getting groceries and providing proof of the awaiting Instacart driver, police arrested him. One said he "looked like" a looter. He spent two days in jail and the charges were later dropped.

“There was no basis for arresting him,” Terry Gilbert, one of the man's lawyers, told Cleveland.com. “The police could have accommodated him. But they put him in jail instead. It was typical of the aggressive nature of officers that day.”

Other lawsuits over curfew arrests have been filed, including one by Anthony Body of the Bail Project.

Body, who both lives and works downtown, was cited twice by Cleveland police during the curfew. Once while biking over the Detroit-Superior bridge back into downtown after grabbing lunch and later that day while biking from his residence to the Justice Center, where he works. He was arrested after the second citation and spent the night in jail.


***

(Original story 1/26/21): Mehdi Mollahasani, a downtown Cleveland resident of Middle Eastern descent, has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the city of Cleveland for his arrest on May 31, 2020 while attempting to get a grocery order during the city's post-protest crackdown.

Following the demonstrations and violence during the May 30th George Floyd protest in Cleveland, Mayor Frank Jackson instituted a curfew for the downtown area to physically prevent demonstrators from gathering again.

The curfew zones and times were almost immediately criticized as over-broad overreactions for which the city provided little to no justification but nevertheless included militarized officers and blocked highway exits.

Regardless, in accordance with the order, residents who lived downtown were asked to remain at home except for work purposes or to gather essential items.

Mollahasani says in his lawsuit that he did just that — leaving his residence on East 9th to retrieve an Instacart order from a delivery driver who had been stopped by cops outside the restricted downtown zone. Before making it four blocks, he was confronted by Cleveland police officers who "harassed him, and baselessly accused him of looting."

Mollahasani hadn't even attended the protest the previous day, let alone participated in any looting.

Despite showing proof of residency, and despite doing nothing more extraordinary than getting groceries and providing proof of the awaiting Instacart driver, police arrested him.

One said he "looked like" a looter.

"In spite of his compliance with every order of the officers, Cleveland Division of Police officers arrested him and caused him to be incarcerated in the Cuyahoga County Jail for days during the novel Coronavirus pandemic. He was later charged criminally and forced to defend himself in court. All charges against him were dismissed," Mollahasani's lawyers at Friedman, Gilbert + Gerhardstein said in a release.

His was far from the only arrest for violating the downtown curfew, which a U.S. District Court Judge ruled recently was problematic in general, saying simply being downtown after the curfew was not sufficient probable cause to arrest people.

That was, however, how cops interpreted it.

Notable among the other arrests was that of Anthony Body, a Bail Project employee, for violating curfew despite having his court-issued ID and traveling into downtown to do his job at the Justice Center.

About half of the 120 cases stemming from May 30 have been dropped to date. About 50 of those remaining involve curfew violations. Given the judge's ruling, those will likely be dropped or result in fines.

“The defendant police officers abused their power in the most unconscionable way when they arrested Mehdi off the street and threw him into the notorious Cuyahoga County Jail for days for absolutely no reason,” said Sarah Gelsomino, partner at Friedman, Gilbert + Gerhardstein. “The City encouraged their police officers to sweep people off the streets and into the jail in order to prevent additional protest, and they did so without any concern for civilians, like Mehdi, who were living legally within the curfew zone. The City and the defendant officers must account for this blatantly unconstitutional and unreasonable behavior of their officers.”

See related PDF Mollahassani_-_Complaint_and_Civil_Cover_Sheet__231.pdf

We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Cleveland Scene. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Cleveland Scene, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.

Email us at [email protected].

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club


Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.


Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.


Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club for as little as $5 a month.